Brought to you in collaboration with Sunday Lawn Care. We only partner with brands that reflect our values and standards, ensuring content that benefits you.
Maintaining a lush, green lawn can be challenging, especially when dealing with issues like heat stress, pet damage, or diseased grass. Selecting the right lawn care product is crucial to address these problems effectively. This comparison examines two different approaches to DIY lawn care solutions: Sunday Lawn Care and traditional fertilizer solutions. Let’s see how they compare in terms of customization, ingredients, ease of use, price/value, and user experience.
Customization
These lawn care solutions offer similar results; however, their adaptability to your specific lawn care needs can vary.
Sunday
Sunday’s customized lawn care plans handle all the seasonal demands that your lawn faces with a customized strategy that considers your location, climate data, and satellite imagery. With the company’s hassle-free subscription service, you can have a green lawn year-round without wasting time and money with guesswork or trial and error. The plans also provide you with a free soil-testing kit.
sunday lawn care lifestyle
Traditional Fertilizers
Be prepared to do your own research and customization when using traditional lawn care products. These brands typically offer pre-formulated fertilizers and grass seeds that are not formulated for specific lawn types or regional conditions. The application and planning are entirely your responsibility.
close-up of spraying weeds
Ingredients and Environmental Impact
The ingredients in lawn care treatments are the most significant factor in safely keeping your lawn green all year. This is how these brands compare ingredient-wise.
Sunday
Sunday provides bio-based formulas containing safe and effective ingredients, such as soy protein, seaweed, molasses, and beet juice extract. Developed with the oversight of renowned turf science expert Dr. Frank Rossi, these formulations deliver vital nutrients to your lawn without harming humans, pets, or the planet. Sunday’s lawn care plans also avoid synthetic chemicals and toxic pesticides.
Sunday lawn care pet grass seed
Traditional Fertilizers
Like many conventional lawn care brands, traditional formulas contain standard fertilizer compounds, such as synthetic nutrients and weed control chemicals. Some formulas contain ingredients like Penoxsulam and Sulfentrazone. Although these formulas are relatively safe, high concentrations of some ingredients can potentially impact children, pets, and water sources.
close-up of lawn
Ease of Use
Ease of use is essential for do-it-yourself (DIY) lawn care, especially for busy workers and homemakers. Let’s see how these two brands compare in this category.
Sunday
Conveniently delivered to your home seasonally, Sunday’s lawn care products don’t require any complex mixing or measuring. Just attach the pre-mixed nutrient pouch to a hose and spray. Sunday’s customized plans also don’t require you to stick to complex fertilizer schedules or visit any store. Throughout the year, you’ll receive the boxes at your front door with all the supplies you need to apply at the appropriate time.
sunday lawn care products
Traditional Fertilizers
You can find traditional lawn care products at most garden centers and big-box stores. Since each season requires a different product selection and application, you must devote substantial time, effort, and information-gathering to effectively serve your lawn’s needs, unless you are a seasoned lawn pro. This option may also require return trips to the retail store where you bought the product.
Garden center
Price and Value
Getting value for your money spent on lawn care products involves several factors. Let’s compare the value difference between these two lawn care brands.
Sunday
Sunday offers custom lawn plans starting at $55. However, plans typically range from $119 to $259 per year, depending on the size of your lawn. The rate includes custom lawn plans, product selection, seasonal delivery, unlimited expert support, and a free soil analysis. This brand also regularly offers mystery savings and free gifts.
sunday lawn care after photo
Traditional Fertilizers
Priced at about $50 to $150 per season, traditional fertilizers’ upfront costs are typically lower than Sunday’s. However, the lack of DIY customization opens you up to potential additional expenses, such as purchasing extra products or tools, and losing money from trial and error. You also may encounter opportunity costs for the time devoted to lawn care instead of more enjoyable or profitable activities.
hand using tools to Tend lawn
User Experience
Sunday and traditional fertilizer companies have excellent reputations in the lawn care market. However, they differ significantly in user experience.
Sunday
Sunday has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and a consistent 4.5 out of 5 rating across most consumer review platforms for three primary reasons:
The company provides an effective lawn care system that is safe for pets and kids.
The easy plans come with a risk-free guarantee that appeals to first-timers.
The company provides exceptional customer support with straightforward online dashboards, seasonal reminders, and one-on-one support with a human team member whenever needed.
sunday lawn care after photo
Traditional Fertilizers
Well-established lawn care brands typically get consistently good consumer reviews for product quality and effectiveness. However, since traditional brands rely on retailers to service their customers, the quality of customer support depends on the store where you bought the product. In addition, without in-house support from a human representative, you’re left seeking advice from store employees or an online forum. This is why these products are more suited for experienced and professional gardeners.
garden retailer
Bottom Line
Feature
Sunday
Traditional Fertilizer Solutions
Customization
Offers personalized lawn care plans based on your location, climate data, and satellite imagery. Includes a free soil-testing kit to tailor nutrient applications.
Provides pre-formulated fertilizers and grass seeds without customization. Users must research and plan applications themselves.
Ingredients & Environmental Impact
Utilizes bio-based, eco-friendly ingredients like soy protein, seaweed, molasses, and beet juice extract. Avoids synthetic chemicals and toxic pesticides, making it safe for humans, pets, and the environment.
Contains traditional synthetic nutrients and weed control chemicals. While effective, high concentrations may impact children, pets, and water sources.
Ease of Use
Delivers pre-measured, ready-to-use products directly to your home. Simply attach the nutrient pouch to a hose and spray. No complex mixing or scheduling required.
Available at most garden centers and big-box stores. Requires users to select appropriate products for each season and manage application schedules manually.
Price & Value
Custom plans start at $55, typically ranging from $119 to $259 per year, depending on lawn size. Includes soil analysis, seasonal delivery, and expert support. Offers promotions and free gifts.
Priced between $50 to $150 per season. Lower upfront costs but may incur additional expenses due to lack of customization and potential trial-and-error.
User Experience
Highly rated with an A+ from the Better Business Bureau and consistent 4.5/5 consumer reviews. Praised for effective, pet- and kid-safe products, risk-free guarantee, and exceptional customer support.
Well-established brands with good reviews for product quality. Customer support varies by retailer, and users often rely on store employees or online forums for assistance.
Sunday and traditional fertilizers offer effective DIY solutions to getting a greener lawn. However, traditional fertilizers feature a conventional DIY approach to lawn care with standard industry chemicals, while Sunday offers a modern, customized plan with eco-friendly ingredients.
A Sunday lawn care plan is best if you want green lawns year-round with an eco-friendly plan that requires little effort or time commitment.
shop our top pick
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *